Can Google’s Smartphone Outsmart Apple?

After taking over Motorola, Google is planning to use its new arm of expertise by offering a smart-phone in 2013, so far dubbed by media as X-phone. This would be a direct competitor to Apple’s iphone, offering better technical features and amenities than iphones.

No matter how technically superior it might sound like, I have strong doubt about Google’s success of this head-on attack strategy to counter Apple’s smart-phones. Two fundamental issues of branding are of concern here. First, one-to-one matching of technical features might backfire once Apple or Samsung comes up with better phones than they currently have in their inventory. For the sake of debate, if we accept that technical superiority of X-phone would beat iphone, who told you that iphone is sitting idle by now and would not come up with better features by the time X-phone is in the market? What about Samsung? Do you think they are sleeping only to wake up and see X-phone making them bite the dust?

Second, even though technical features are important, it is not always the technical superiority that gives the winning edge in branding to increase mind and market share. Apple is already an image leader in this segment, if not the market leader by volume. Beating Apple on “image department” by Motorola and Google is a questionable strategy. Consumers often have perceptions about brands which are difficult to break by technical attacks only. It requires huge and consistent investment in image building activities. After sale of Motorola to Google, added up with already much tarnished image of Motorola, coupled with Google’s previous hardware market failure of Chromebook, I humbly doubt how far X-phone can push the image contrary to Apple or Samsung.

After all, the art of branding is not about one-to-one beauty contest!


About 1mmarketing

Working as Associate Professor, School of Business, United International University, Bangladesh; a North-American graduate, with doctoral studies from UUM, Malaysia; cherishing a wide-view of the world, with multiple interests in culture, people, traveling, and specifically marketing science. I have a colorful and diversified background with a blend of corporate experience, research, consulting, training, public speaking and teaching. I love to write about marketing issues that affect our lives, and talk about its direction that would promote the greatest human welfare.
This entry was posted in Branding and Communication, Digital Marketing, Hard Core Branding, Strategic Marketing and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Can Google’s Smartphone Outsmart Apple?

  1. Imran Hossen Zico says:

    Thank you sir for this nice article. Your blog is a great source of gathering knowledge about branding and marketing. But I have an argue, you always post your articles about international brands. It will be very grateful to us, if you write something about our Bangladeshi brands.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s